A terrible deal for Sound Energy? Gary Newman reviews...

Tom Winnifrith Bearcast: thank you, thank you, thank you & what does one do at "Woke" PC Christmas parties these days? Listen HERE

It has been fascinating watching Sound Energy (SOU) play out over the past few years, but probably less so if you’ve actually owned shares in it. This oil and gas company was one of the darlings of AIM until quite recently, and at its peak in early 2017 reached a market cap of close to £700 million, and a share price of over 90p. But since then reality has set in and the share price has collapsed. It has been a great example of just how high the market cap of some of these companies can be inflated to, providing there is a good story and you have the brokers and PR machine on your side. The speculation largely related to just how many billions its Tendrara licence in Morocco would ultimately be worth and how many tcf of gas would be proven to be present there, with CEO James Parsons giving investors all the encouragement that they needed to work themselves into a frenzy, with interview comments about each tcf of gas being worth £1 to the share price, amongst many other uber positive statements and talk of what size deal might be done if someone wanted to buy Tendrara. Well now that deal has actually landed – and I have to admit that I am surprised that it is as good as it appears to. But before people start getting excited...

Optibiotix – not my preferred measure of disclosure. Read HERE

I didn’t actually think it’d manage to find a buyer for its 47.5% in the field at all, given that the TE-5 Horst discovery, with 377bcf of 2C contingent resources, was a pre-existing discovery when Sound acquired the licence. Quite a few on social media seemed to think that it was a great deal - of course none of them would have been holding shares in Sound at the time though! - and the headline figure of $112.8 million for 51% of its Tendrara stake (24.2% of the field) actually looks pretty good compared to a market cap of circa £75 million (pre the news). Currently the deal - which is for the ‘Eastern Morocco Portfolio’, but basically means Tendrara - is only a non-binding heads of terms agreement and must be approved by shareholders, but given that originally Sound signed non-disclosure agreements with 23 companies, and by the looks of it this is the best offer, I’d be surprised if an alternative came along.

Rolls Royce remains an attractive long cycle stock considers Chris Bailey HERE

As for the offer itself, when you look into it in more details it is nowhere near as good as the headline figure would suggest, as $54.3 million of it is in cash, with the remainder being a free carry on any future capital expenditure - relating to its remaining 23.3% share of Tendrara - that it would have had to contribute towards reaching first gas. Of that $54.3 million cash component, only 55% will be received on completion of the deal, or just under $30 million; with a further 30% coming when a final investment decision is made in the future; and the remaining 15% being payable within 60 days of first gas production. At this stage the buyer is simply an unnamed UK registered private limited company, which I must admit always makes me wonder why it is still remaining anonymous even after an agreement has been signed, albeit non-binding. It also has the option to acquire a further 9% of Sound’s remaining interest on the same terms within a year of a deal being signed. It seems likely that plenty more drilling is going to be needed at Tendrara before it is anywhere near moving towards the production stage, which I’d expect to be at least a couple of years down the line, assuming it even happens, and it isn’t 100% clear from the RNS as to whether the free carry actually covers Sound for its share of any further exploration and appraisal drills across the block.

InnovaDerma – reasons for “excellent progress” share price fall clearer? Read HERE

My reading of it is that it doesn’t cover any such drilling expenditure, as the RNS says that the free carry is for Sounds future CAPEX requirements to achieve first gas. So, it could well be on the hook to pay its share of future drilling costs. Even if we were to assume that the RNS is just badly worded and the deal covers any drilling costs, the company still isn’t exactly in a great position. It did have cash in the bank of £11 million as at the end of June 2019, and with the initial payment from this deal that would add somewhere around £24 million, depending on the exchange rate at the time of completion, so £35 million less any expenditure since then. But it also has £21.3 million to repay in June 2021 relating to the 5 year secured bonds, plus there are £6.2 million of trade payables that are listed as being due within 12 months (it is unclear from the account notes exactly what they relate to and whether some or all of it could be deferred). So that would leave at best around £14 million (ignoring the trade payables) and with annual admin running costs of circa £4 million per annum – allowing for the 50% reduction that has been implemented for those. It will be interesting, given the performance of the company, if any of those cost reductions include director remuneration, which stood at a total of £1.76 million for 2018, with £1.23 million of that being related to just the base salaries, and James Parsons earning roughly £1 million for his entire remuneration package!

Read HERE: CAP-XX – “a successful year for the company”… or that more CrAP? (XX)…

So, the company doesn’t look in any danger of having to raise further funds in the near future, but I can’t see that money lasting through until Tendrara production, if and when that actually happens, and especially if it does have to pay its share of any drilling costs in the meantime. I know that some will be looking at this and seeing a potential bargain based on the fact that it has traded at much higher share prices in the past, but based on everything I’ve mentioned here, I would seriously question how it can justify the current market cap – given that there is no certainty of future cash flows from Tendrara – and definitely see it as a share to continue avoiding. This should also serve as a good case study as to why you shouldn’t pay too much attention to what the BOD of any company says and should always remember that part of their job is to promote their business to potential investors, so they will always paint a rosy picture. Even RNSs don’t always tell the full story and the best way to avoid being stung on a share like this one is to maintain a certain amount of scepticism about what is being claimed, and always question why, if the business is actually worth the amounts being claimed, the City professionals have managed to miss it, and have left private investors to pick up the shares at a huge discount to the claimed value!

Read HERE: So how would Ed Croft & Stockopedia rate mystery Business A?

Filed under: Sound Energy, Bearcast, Optibiotix, Rolls Royce, InnovaDerma, CAP-XX, Ed Croft

PetroTal - failure of finance & corporate governance control. Sell says Peter Brailey...

11/21/2019

Time for General Inaction but still short Sirius Minerals argues Lucian Miers

11/20/2019

RiverFort Global Opportunities - remains a buy say the team at HotStockRockets

11/19/2019

Volex - positive interims, a good share tip and now we upgrade...

11/18/2019

Oops...FirstGroup did it again. Chris Bailey writes...

11/15/2019

Eco Atlantic - following Jethro & Joe wells initial results analysis, Peter Brailey reviews...

11/14/2019

KEFI Minerals - financial & Tulu Kapi project updates... shares soar again & stance upgraded

11/13/2019

Bluebird Merchant Ventures - Gubong permit received, shares very cheap?...

11/12/2019

Rolls Royce remains an attractive long cycle stock considers Chris Bailey

11/11/2019

A terrible deal for Sound Energy? Gary Newman reviews...

11/08/2019

Marks & Spencer - you know what happens when there are no believers...

11/07/2019

Kicking when down - ref. Sirius Minerals. Tom Winnifrith writes...

11/06/2019

Columbus Energy Resources - Saffron prospect spud update, drilling excitement ahoy...

11/05/2019

Image Scan Holdings - a buy considers the HotStockRockets team...

11/04/2019

Large-cap earnings frenzy - Shell, Lloyds, BT, Crest Nicholson & DS Smith. Buys amongst them?

11/01/2019

Tom Winnifrith reviews - is lying and fraud acceptable on the London Market?

10/30/2019

M&G - a spin-off opportunity? Chris Bailey reviews...

10/29/2019

Solid State - half-year trading update, still a buy?

10/28/2019

Ariana Resources - a junior gold conviction buy? Nigel Somerville reviews...

10/25/2019

Whitbread - a buy at/around the forty quid level?

10/24/2019

After the Woodford scandal...how is the house of Hargreaves Lansdown looking?

10/23/2019

If it sounds too good to be true...which brings me back to Versarien writes Tom Winnifrith...

10/22/2019

JKX Oil & Gas - a buy at current levels says Gary Newman

10/21/2019

Ariana Resources - key licence renewal, value soon to be highlighted?

10/18/2019

Next plc - would I be selling too? Reviews Chris Bailey

10/17/2019

Yourgene Health - much more to come? A review from HotStockRockets...

10/16/2019

OptiBiotix Health - looks good reasons to continue to consider a strong buy

10/15/2019

Bushveld Minerals currently offers a buying opportunity says Gary Newman

10/14/2019

Altyn - pleasing Resources & Reserves upgrade, remains a gold recovery buy

10/11/2019

GVC ups its numbers again - still happy to make a bet on this one

10/10/2019

Staffing naturally struggles but easyJet continues to impress says Chris Bailey

10/09/2019

Good luck BP shareholders with the man to win over the millennials says Chris Bailey

10/08/2019

Could Ted Baker be a zero? Tom Winnifrith reviews...

10/07/2019

BigDish - evil spin doctor, the Sith Lord Zak Mir, needs to get his act together...

10/04/2019

Tesco and Metro Bank prove management matters

10/03/2019

I descend to the AIM cesspit but emerge still loving up Breedon Group says Chris Bailey

10/02/2019

Big Sofa - interims & placing, Strong buy says Tom Winnifrith for HotStockRockets

10/01/2019

Purplebricks - time to get off the fence, sell at 110p says Lucian Miers

09/30/2019

Columbus Energy Resources - SWP updated prospectivity, drilling excitement ahoy

09/27/2019

Thoughts on PZ Cussons & on Aston Martin raising money at 12% from Chris Bailey

09/26/2019

The Penny Finally Drops at PureCircle says Lucian Miers

09/25/2019

Is it good or bad that M&S loses another CFO? Chris Bailey reviews...

09/24/2019

Petra Diamonds - a speculative buy suggests Gary Newman

09/23/2019

Next, Diageo & Johnson Matthey - large caps are all about levels says Chris Bailey

09/20/2019

Petropavlovsk - remains a buy after interims say Tom Winnifrith & Steve Moore

09/19/2019

Eco Atlantic - good value or guidance required from a film star? Peter Brailey writes...

09/18/2019

Versarien - the point at which it must deliver is approaching says Lucian Miers

09/17/2019

5 slam-dunk sells for 2019 - September update. Nigel Somerville writes...

09/16/2019

Barclays & Lloyds fess up to new PPI horrors... but that is fine. Chris Bailey writes...

09/12/2019

Finding it hard to find any reason not to invest in Jadestone Energy says Gary Newman

09/11/2019

Ferrexpo - time for another go says Lucian Miers...

09/10/2019

Intu Properties - when even a takeover cannot help...

09/09/2019

Boohoo says boo hoo to the doubters. Chris Bailey writes...

09/06/2019

President Energy can weather the economic problems in Argentina considers Gary Newman

09/05/2019

IQE - why that shiny new debt facility?

09/04/2019

Horizonte Minerals - after positive news on funding...

09/03/2019

Whilst some go back to school, M&S goes back to the FTSE-250...

09/02/2019

Optibiotix - interims do not impress but it really is a strong buy argues Tom Winnifrith

08/30/2019

Another Crack at Wayfair says Lucian Miers

08/29/2019

Motels, gold and the stock no active investor should buy. Chris Bailey writes...

08/28/2019

ITM Power - a buy on a long term investment basis considers Peter Brailey

08/27/2019

Rockhopper Exploration - update following further positive news on Sea Lion

08/23/2019

Ferguson plc & woe betide the future of the UK stockmarket?

08/22/2019

Wood Group - I remain a buyer says Chris Bailey

08/21/2019

ConvaTec - still a buy after further management change?

08/20/2019

A share tip of the year for 2019 update...

08/19/2019

GVC raises numbers but please no more number of the beast share sales says Chris Bailey

08/16/2019

The thoughts of Lucian Miers on the Burford fiasco

08/15/2019

Gold - rushing ever-higher. What I will do reviews Nigel Somerville...

08/14/2019

Eco Atlantic - what to do after a great first drill?

08/13/2019

Spin City at G4S. Chris Bailey writes...

08/12/2019

Aviva, Cineworld and Funding Circle reviewed by Chris Bailey

08/09/2019

Thomas Cook - doing the Fandango. Lucian Miers writes...

08/08/2019

Chris Bailey confesses he is now a Dominos Pizza customer, but to buy the shares?

08/07/2019

Volex - ahead of expectations. Buy say Tom Winnifrith & Steve Moore

08/06/2019

Petra Diamonds could still turnaround considers Gary Newman

08/05/2019

Opportunities in Barclays, Lloyds and ConvaTec? Chris Bailey reviews...

08/02/2019

Fresnillo - big drop in share price an opportunity? Gary Newman reviews...

08/01/2019

Columbus Energy Resources - a buy ahead of South West Peninsula drilling?

07/31/2019

Tesla Q2 another milestone on the road to bankruptcy and ruin says Lucian Miers

07/30/2019

Amino Technologies - a recovery buy suggest Tom Winnifrith & Steve Moore

07/29/2019

I remain calm and collected amidst the heat, M&A activity & as Sage stumbles says Chris Bailey

07/26/2019

RockRose Energy tip up nearly 450%, so what now reviews Gary Newman

07/25/2019

PZ Cussons - losses in Africa... but still a buy? Chris Bailey reviews...

07/24/2019

Block Energy - let winner run or take a healthy profit?

07/23/2019

Sell Netflix short as US subscribers back off says Lucian Miers

07/22/2019

OptiBiotix Health - scientific and commercial update adding to confidence?

07/19/2019

Thoughts On Thomas Cook & Kier from Lucian Miers

07/18/2019

Burberry - excitements sufficient? Chris Bailey reviews

07/17/2019

KEFI Minerals - Q2 2019 operational update, shares remain a Buy says HotStockRockets

07/16/2019

Angling Direct could have long-term potential says Gary Newman

07/15/2019

Hurricane Energy - Lancaster early production system delivering, Buy says Peter Brailey

07/12/2019

I remain to be convinced that asset sale will justify the valuation of Sound Energy says Gary Newman

07/11/2019

Imperial Brands goes progressive on its dividend...and the market likes it

07/10/2019

Tesla and me - Chris Bailey writes...

07/09/2019

Woodford Patient Capital Trust - still a sell says Lucian Miers

07/08/2019

Versarien - the only question is WHEN do the shares collapse says Lucian Miers

07/05/2019

Sainsbury - still searching for a strategy?

07/04/2019

Creightons - we having said we expected the results to highlight the value…

07/03/2019

PetroTal - rapid growth possible; Buy says Peter Brailey

07/02/2019

RISK WARNING & DISCLAIMER - FiveFreeShareTips.com tips are provided by independent authors via a common carrier platform and do not represent the opinions of FiveFreeShareTips.com. FiveFreeShareTips.com does not accept responsibility for or make any warranties in connection with or recommend that you or any third party rely on such information. The information available at FiveFreeShareTips.com and via emails you receive from [email protected] are for your general information and use and are not intended to address your particular requirements. In particular, the information does not constitute any form of advice or recommendation by the tipsters or FiveFreeShareTips.com and is not intended to be relied upon by users in making (or refraining from making) any investment decisions. Trading shares involves the risk of loss. The tipsters and FiveFreeShareTips.com shall not be liable for any losses or other damages incurred. The value of investments can go up or down and the past is not necessarily a guide of future performance.

Five Free Share Tips?

. . . . . . . . . .

Well actually it will be six. One every week day and one on Sunday, each landing with you at 11 AM sharp.

The Details

Unlike other services (which may always have a vested interest) we pride ourselves on our impartiality and cover all small caps including AIM. the Standard List, The Wider Main Market and NEX.

We cover small caps, penny shares, FTSE 350 stocks and blue chips. We look for red hot penny shares, Warren Buffett style value investments with yield and growth stocks. There is no technical analysis in our work just solid fundamental analysis from a team of experts with decades of stockmarket experience.

You will not agree with all we publish but if you are interested in small caps you cannot afford to ignore it either. Yo'll never be charged for the free share tips from Five Free Share Tips and given the star writers involved you know that they will move share prices.

There's no telephone number or postal address required and there is no charge, ever, for your Five Free Share Tips membership. Just free shares tips every day apart from Saturday And each day's share tip will not just be a few thoughts cobbled together but will be detailed analysis from experts.

Our experts do not just earn their living from writing. All own shares. If they own shares in a stock they cover they will declare it and will not sell until after advising a sell to our readers. And why not our tips are so good that why shouldn't our readers put their money where their mouth is?

Don't just take our word for it! Judge us on the calibre of our free share tips and join today to start receiving them from September 1 2017. If you don't like what you get delivered to your inbox unsubscribe and you will never hear from us again. So why not give it a go? Sign Up Now

The Team

We've put together a panel of top tipsters, including:

Tom Winnifrith, in his 27th year writing about shares, noted fraudbuster & dubbed "The maverick Tipster"

Chris Bailey, City whizz kid turned financial guru, rated as one of the top 50 commentators on shares on twitter, founder of Financial Orbit

Steve Moore, has worked with Tom Winnifrith for all bar 3 weeks of his working life - a noted commentator on value stocks

Malcolm Stacey, The Grandfather of Share Blogging, the founder of ShareCrazy & a best selling autthor of stockmarket books

Lucian Miers, the Bard of the Boleyn, one of the UK's best known short sellers

Gary Newman, writes about value investing on AIM, speciality is in share tips on oil and mining companies

Nigel Somerville, The Deputy Sheriff of AIM, an expert in forensic analysis a skill used to bust frauds but also to tip true value investments

The team from HotStockRockets, specialising in AIM and small cap shares which will fly on a three month view

Sign Up Now

UK Investor Show 2018

Remember to book your place at the UK Investor Show 2018. The UK’s top investment show taking place on Saturday 21 April 2018 at the Queen Elizabeth II Conference Centre in Westminster, London. The show will feature a unique line-up of top speakers including Nigel Wray, tech queen Vin Murria, Dave Lenigas, Mark Slater, Tom Winnifrith, Adam Reynolds, Ed, Croft, Nick Leslau Luke Johnson and Dr Johnny Hon as well as 135 exhibiting small cap companies.

To reserve your ticket, visit UK Investor Show.

Risk Warning & Disclaimer

The hot share tips given here are of necessity, general. They cannot relate to the individual circumstances of investors. Anyone considering following the share tips contained here should seek independent advice from a Financial Conduct Authority authorised Stockbroker or Financial Adviser. We cannot be held liable if individuals suffer losses through following share tips contained on this site or emailed out as free share tips. The value of investments can go down as well as up. The past is not necessarily a guide to future performance. Investing in shares can lose you part or all of your capital although the potential returns are theoretically unlimited. The difference between the buy share price and the sell share price for smaller company shares (penny shares) can be significant. Profits from dealing in shares may be liable to tax - the level of tax and bases of relief from tax are subject to change. Changes in the rates of exchange may have an adverse effect on the value or price of an investment in sterling terms if it is denominated in a foreign currency. Some of the shares recommended on this site will be smaller company shares. By their nature such investments can be relatively illiquid and thus hard to trade. And that makes such investments more of a high risk than larger company shares (or 'small caps'/'penny shares'). FiveFreeShareTips.com & its sister site ShareProphets.com defines a smaller company share as any stock traded on AIM or NEX or which has a market capitalisation of less than £300 million.